Example
Salary of GBP 50,000 versus GBP 45,000 plus GBP 10,000 bonus
A worked example showing why a package with higher variable pay can still be weaker in spendable-pay terms than it looks on paper.
Scenario
This is one of the clearest fixed-versus-variable comparisons: a cleaner GBP 50,000 salary against GBP 45,000 plus a GBP 10,000 target bonus. On paper the second package looks bigger, but it is also more dependent on bonus treatment and payout certainty.
What to notice
The bonus-heavy package can still lose some of its shine once the bonus is viewed as marginal taxable pay rather than as clean salary. Even if the gross total is higher, the spendable result may not dominate by as much as the headline package suggests.
Practical interpretation
This is a good reminder that package comparison should start with certainty and after-tax cash. If the difference only looks compelling before deductions and before bonus reliability is considered, the higher-target package may not be the obvious winner.
Best next step
Use the salary vs bonus calculator for the direct comparison and the job offer comparison calculator if this is part of a wider role decision. The framework sits in How to compare salary, bonus, pension, and job offers.
Related guides
Guide
How to compare salary, bonus, pension, and job offers
A practical framework for comparing compensation properly, using spendable pay, pension value, and decision quality rather than one headline package number.
6 min read
Guide
Bonus tax explained UK
A practical guide to why a bonus can feel heavily taxed, how annual tax logic works, and what to watch for when you compare bonus-heavy pay with higher base salary.
6 min read
How to use PayPath here
Run the relevant calculator for your live numbers, review the methodology if the assumptions matter to your decision, and save the strongest scenarios in the workspace if you are comparing more than one option.